Skip to main content

Table 3 Results of evaluation study of mutation-based testing

From: Testing of aspect-oriented programs: difficulties and lessons learned based on theoretical and practical experience

   

Mut.

Mut.

Mut.

 

Equiv.

Equiv.

  

Killed by

Added

Application

#C a

#A

G1

G2

G3

Total

Aut.

Man.l

Anom.

Alive

original

TCs

           

TCs

 

1. BankingSystem

9

6

108

2

26

136

68

18

50

50

2. Telecom

6

3

82

2

27

111

46

10

12

53

31

4

3. ProdLine

8

8

158

0

41

199

125

16

58

58

4. FactorialOptimiser

1

1

14

0

15

29

8

1

6

15

14

5. MusicOnline

7

2

47

0

10

57

25

2

5

27

22

2

6. VendingMachine

1

3

82

2

29

113

58

13

8

47

23

5

7. PointBoundsChecker

1

1

46

0

24

70

32

10

28

28

8. StackManager

4

3

34

0

11

45

24

0

21

21

9. PointShadowManager

2

1

38

0

12

50

25

5

4

21

13

2

10. Math

1

1

16

0

4

20

13

2

0

7

4

1

11. AuthSystem

3

2

45

0

7

52

28

1

3

21

17

2

12. SeqGen

8

4

33

0

7

40

19

8

3

18

4

3

Total

51

35

703

6

213

922

471

42

85

366

285

19

  1. aIt considers only relevant classes, excluding the driver ones