Studies | QA | Quality | Studies | QA | Quality | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ID | Reference | Year | 1 | 2 | 3 | Sc | Des | ID | Reference | Year | 1 | 2 | 3 | Sc | Des |
01 | [13] Austin | 2013 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E | 28 | [62] Line | 2008 | Y | P | P | 2.0 | V |
02 | [40] Hsu | 2008 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G | 29 | [37] Mainka | 2012 | Y | P | Y | 2.5 | E |
03 | [53] Holm | 2011 | P | Y | N | 1.5 | G | 30 | [11] Geer | 2002 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
04 | [41] Bechtsoudis | 2012 | Y | P | Y | 2.5 | E | 31 | [48] Traore | 2011 | Y | P | N | 1.5 | G |
05 | [42] Sarraute | 2011 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E | 32 | [39] Benkhelifa | 2013 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G |
06 | [14] Khoury | 2011 | P | Y | N | 1.5 | G | 33 | [22] Salas | 2014 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
07 | [34] Antunes | 2015 | Y | Y | N | 2.0 | V | 34 | [23] Büchler | 2012 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
08 | [15] Xu | 2012 | P | P | Y | 2.0 | V | 35 | [56] Sandouka | 2009 | Y | P | P | 2.0 | V |
09 | [43] Shen | 2011 | Y | P | Y | 2.5 | E | 36 | [24] Liu | 2012 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
10 | [35] Mendes | 2011 | P | Y | P | 2.0 | V | 37 | [52] Masood | 2011 | Y | P | Y | 2.5 | E |
11 | [16] Fong | 2008 | Y | Y | P | 2.5 | E | 38 | [25] Igure | 2008 | Y | Y | P | 2.5 | E |
12 | [65] Williams | 2012 | Y | Y | P | 2.5 | E | 39 | [64] Khoury | 2011 | Y | P | N | 1.5 | G |
13 | [44] Bou-harb | 2014 | P | Y | Y | 2.5 | E | 40 | [26] Leibolt | 2010 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G |
14 | [45] Kasinathan | 2013 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G | 41 | [27] Fonseca | 2010 | Y | P | P | 2.0 | V |
15 | [46] Xing | 2010 | Y | P | Y | 2.5 | E | 42 | [49] Jajodia | 2005 | P | P | Y | 3.0 | E |
16 | [36] Antunes | 2009 | Y | Y | P | 2.5 | E | 43 | [50] Blackwell | 2014 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
17 | [54] Holik | 2014 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E | 44 | [28] Prandini | 2010 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
18 | [17] Avramescu | 2013 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E | 45 | [59] Dimkov | 2010 | Y | Y | Y | 2.0 | V |
19 | [57] Ridgewell | 2013 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G | 46 | [60] Stepien | 2012 | Y | P | Y | 2.5 | E |
20 | [18] Walden | 2008 | P | Y | P | 2.0 | V | 47 | [29] Badawy | 2013 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G |
21 | [19] Mink | 2006 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G | 48 | [30] Curphey | 2006 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G |
22 | [55] Tondel | 2008 | P | Y | P | 2.0 | V | 49 | [31] Huang | 2005 | P | P | P | 1.5 | G |
23 | [20] Armando | 2010 | Y | P | P | 2.0 | V | 50 | [32] Doupé | 2010 | P | Y | P | 2.0 | V |
24 | [63] Dahl | 2006 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E | 51 | [51] Vegendla | 2016 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
25 | [47] Mclaughlin | 2010 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E | 52 | [61] Casseli | 2016 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
26 | [58] Somorovsky | 2012 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E | 53 | [38] Antunes | 2016 | Y | Y | Y | 3.0 | E |
27 | [21] Garn | 2014 | Y | Y | Y | 1.5 | G | 54 | [33] Awang | 2015 | Y | Y | P | 2.5 | E |