Skip to main content

Table 3 Quality studies scores

From: Overview and open issues on penetration test

Studies QA Quality Studies QA Quality
ID Reference Year 1 2 3 Sc Des ID Reference Year 1 2 3 Sc Des
01 [13] Austin 2013 Y Y Y 3.0 E 28 [62] Line 2008 Y P P 2.0 V
02 [40] Hsu 2008 P P P 1.5 G 29 [37] Mainka 2012 Y P Y 2.5 E
03 [53] Holm 2011 P Y N 1.5 G 30 [11] Geer 2002 Y Y Y 3.0 E
04 [41] Bechtsoudis 2012 Y P Y 2.5 E 31 [48] Traore 2011 Y P N 1.5 G
05 [42] Sarraute 2011 Y Y Y 3.0 E 32 [39] Benkhelifa 2013 P P P 1.5 G
06 [14] Khoury 2011 P Y N 1.5 G 33 [22] Salas 2014 Y Y Y 3.0 E
07 [34] Antunes 2015 Y Y N 2.0 V 34 [23] Büchler 2012 Y Y Y 3.0 E
08 [15] Xu 2012 P P Y 2.0 V 35 [56] Sandouka 2009 Y P P 2.0 V
09 [43] Shen 2011 Y P Y 2.5 E 36 [24] Liu 2012 Y Y Y 3.0 E
10 [35] Mendes 2011 P Y P 2.0 V 37 [52] Masood 2011 Y P Y 2.5 E
11 [16] Fong 2008 Y Y P 2.5 E 38 [25] Igure 2008 Y Y P 2.5 E
12 [65] Williams 2012 Y Y P 2.5 E 39 [64] Khoury 2011 Y P N 1.5 G
13 [44] Bou-harb 2014 P Y Y 2.5 E 40 [26] Leibolt 2010 P P P 1.5 G
14 [45] Kasinathan 2013 P P P 1.5 G 41 [27] Fonseca 2010 Y P P 2.0 V
15 [46] Xing 2010 Y P Y 2.5 E 42 [49] Jajodia 2005 P P Y 3.0 E
16 [36] Antunes 2009 Y Y P 2.5 E 43 [50] Blackwell 2014 Y Y Y 3.0 E
17 [54] Holik 2014 Y Y Y 3.0 E 44 [28] Prandini 2010 Y Y Y 3.0 E
18 [17] Avramescu 2013 Y Y Y 3.0 E 45 [59] Dimkov 2010 Y Y Y 2.0 V
19 [57] Ridgewell 2013 P P P 1.5 G 46 [60] Stepien 2012 Y P Y 2.5 E
20 [18] Walden 2008 P Y P 2.0 V 47 [29] Badawy 2013 P P P 1.5 G
21 [19] Mink 2006 P P P 1.5 G 48 [30] Curphey 2006 P P P 1.5 G
22 [55] Tondel 2008 P Y P 2.0 V 49 [31] Huang 2005 P P P 1.5 G
23 [20] Armando 2010 Y P P 2.0 V 50 [32] Doupé 2010 P Y P 2.0 V
24 [63] Dahl 2006 Y Y Y 3.0 E 51 [51] Vegendla 2016 Y Y Y 3.0 E
25 [47] Mclaughlin 2010 Y Y Y 3.0 E 52 [61] Casseli 2016 Y Y Y 3.0 E
26 [58] Somorovsky 2012 Y Y Y 3.0 E 53 [38] Antunes 2016 Y Y Y 3.0 E
27 [21] Garn 2014 Y Y Y 1.5 G 54 [33] Awang 2015 Y Y P 2.5 E
  1. Legend - Y: Yes, N: No, P: Partly, Sc: Score, Des: Description, G: Good, V: Very Good, E: Excellent