Skip to main content

Table 6 Generic Voter

From: Functional test data generation for Simulink-like models

Code

Total mutants

Equivalent mutants

Test data

Generation

Mutation score (%)

p value\(_1\)

p value\(_2\)

Manual

12,566

706

16

\(RP_1\)

65.0

0.039

0

    

\(RR_1\)

68.7

 

0

   

108

\(RP_2\)

84.7

0

0

    

\(RR_2\)

87.2

 

0

   

32

\(RP_1\) +\(RR_1\)

77.5

  
   

216

\(RP_2\) +\(RR_2\)

89.7

  

Simulink

13,267

2,619

16

\(RP_1\)

73.6

0.152

0.001

    

\(RR_1\)

68.1

 

0

   

108

\(RP_2\)

85.2

0.976

0.003

    

\(RR_2\)

85.1

 

0.009

   

32

\(RP_1\) +\(RR_1\)

81.3

  
   

216

\(RP_2\) +\(RR_2\)

90.2

  

Scicos

46,718 (10 %)

32,936

16

\(RP_1\)

70.7

0.470

0

    

\(RR_1\)

70.0

 

0

   

108

\(RP_2\)

84.4

0.944

0

    

\(RR_2\)

84.4

 

0

   

32

\(RP_1\) +\(RR_1\)

73.5

  
   

216

\(RR_2\) +\(RP_2\)

88.0