Testing of aspect-oriented programs: difficulties and lessons learned based on theoretical and practical experience

Journal of the Brazilian Computer Society

Table 8 Results of test adaptation effort measurement—group A and group B

Application Name	Total	%.	Churn LOC TC						Test requirements
	LOC	size	ADD	%ADD	MOD	%MOD	REM	%REM	Equiv.	Bound.	Total
	TC	diff.							classes	values	TC
Group A: OO - OA
1. AbstractFactoryOO	20								4	1	4
AbstractFactoryOA	20	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
2. BooleanOO	29								7	3	7
BooleanOA	37	+ 27.58	8	27.58	1	3.44	0	0
3. BridgeOO	76								16	2	16
BridgeOA	76	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
4. ChessOO	281								28	13	39
ChessOA	302	+ 7.47	21	7.47	8	2.84	0	0
5. InterpreterOO	47								48	2	48
InterpreterOA	47	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
6. VendingMachineOO	41								9	10	10
VendingMachineOA	43	+ 4.87	2	4.87	5	12.19	0	0
7. QuestionDatabaseOO	47								5	3	8
QuestionDatabaseOA	47	0	0	0	6	12.76	0	0
Average		+ 5.70		5.70		4.46		0
Group B: OA - OO
8. ATM-logOA	111								9	5	15
ATM-logOO	111	0	0	0	4	3.6	0	0
9. ChainOfResponsabilityOA	108								6	0	6
ChainOfResponsabilityOO	96	−11.11	0	0	18	16.66	12	11.11
10. FlyweightOA	36								4	4	4
FlyweightOO	36	0	2	5.55	4	11.11	2	5.55
11. MementoOA	31								2	2	3
MementoOO	31	0	0	0	8	25.8	0	0
12. ShopSystemOA	256								22	35	30
ShopSystemOO	256	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
13. TelecomOA	257								12	16	23
TelecomOO	244	−5.05	0	0	15	5.83	13	5.05
7. QuestionDatabaseOA	50								5	5	6
QuestionDatabaseOO	54	+ 8	4	8	2	4	0	0
Average		−1.16		1.93		9.57		3.10